Thursday, May 03, 2007

Another ANC Meeting, Another Meltdown

I went home after the meeting too disgusted and depressed to write anything. If you weren’t there, check out the video at ANC2C02,

and MVSNA President Cary Silverman has provided an excellent recap and thoughtful comments here. About the only good thing to say about it is that the videotaping issue finally seems to be settled.

A few additional thoughts, for what they’re worth.

--Jack Evans’s intervention didn’t work—to state the obvious. The four commissioners reportedly had agreed on two things: 1) to distribute documents to be approved at the meeting (such as minutes, reports, etc.) to all the commissioners before the meeting so they would not have to be read and considered during the meeting, and 2) to elect Kevin Chapple as secretary, replacing Barbara Curtis. The first item—besides just being common courtesy—is absolutely normal routine procedure in any functioning organization; what possibly could be the objection to it? The second item would likely result in a great improvement in record-keeping since, as things stand, no one except the ANC commissioners ever sees the minutes and Kevin is already acting as the de facto public rapporteur for the ANC through his website and newsletter. When the time came, however, Doris Brooks reneged on both. The reelection of the Secretary never even came up. The ball was in the Thorpe/Brooks court, and they effectively told Jack Evans to take a flying leap.

--The poor, hapless Shaw Main Streets representative never had a chance. Personally, I couldn’t care less if they put up the banners or not (or what color they are), but for goodness sake, what harm would they do? But that’s not what this was about. SMS is Alex Padro’s baby, so Leroy Thorpe is automatically against it—whatever it is. Thorpe’s ludicrous accusations about “clandestine meetings” and the complaint that SMS doesn’t communicate with the community are nonsense. I have no connection to SMS, but I’ve attended two public meetings over the past year or so, which I learned about through flyers distributed throughout the neighborhood, not through the SMS website, which I rarely look at. Notices about events are posted in stores and other visible locations, so if you don’t know what SMS is doing, it’s your own fault. (By contrast, I have never yet seen an ANC2C or ECCA flyer left on my block.)

--I’m tired of being tagged with collective guilt for something I have nothing to do with. At every single ANC meeting (and ECCA, for that matter), several people (usually the same ones) get up and start denouncing newcomers/white people (as if they were one and the same) for attitudes that they all allegedly hold. The accusations are always so vague and non-specific that it is impossible to answer them. This happens because those running the meeting encourage it; it does not happen in meeting of other groups even when the same people are present. Here’s the thing: I take responsibility for what I say and do. If you have a problem with something I said or did, let’s talk, and if I’m wrong I’ll do my best to make it right. But don’t assume you know what someone else thinks just because they may fit some category in your mind. And don’t stand up and make vague accusations against a whole class of people and then complain about divisiveness in the community.

--Windy Rahim’s emotional departure speech was partly right: We got the ANC we elected. But she was wrong in one respect: We did not elect a Parliamentarian/Special Assistant who is still the de facto Chairperson. You gotta hand it to Leroy Thorpe—he has done what he said he was going to do after he didn’t get re-elected. But his actions indicate that he places his own ego-tripping before the welfare of the community. Denise Murray lamented last night that she’s still trying to get lights in the park at NJ and O, but let’s not forget that as ANC Chairman last summer, Mr. Thorpe opposed an initiative to do just that simply because it had been spearheaded by Mount Vernon Square without going through him first. To me, that says a lot about where his priorities lie.

10 Comments:

At 5/03/2007 8:46 PM, Anonymous martin Moulton said...

Does Windy's outburst and walk out indicate that Jack Evans will in fact commence meetings in June to address ANC 2C? Mr Thorpe stated, in video tape still being processed, but soon to be posted) that Mr Evans could not replace the ANC.

Fair enough, but Mr Evans and his office can come to hold meetings which address the issues and problems that the ANC fails to put on its agenda like crime and particularly security at 1330 7th St and Scott Montgomery, dog park issues and graffiti.

Evans can also work around the current ANC commission, just as he has been doing for the past few weeks and get some things done. We might also get to hear about the tax and development, civil union and other city wide initiatives Jack sponsors on the City Council the same way other organizations get to hear them when they invite him as a guest.

 
At 5/04/2007 7:16 AM, Anonymous rr 446 said...

i look forward to jack evans leadership in bringing our community together to discuss real issues affecting the community and not getting stuck on ego trips and other agendas.

 
At 5/04/2007 7:19 AM, Blogger Shaw Rez said...

Great commentary.

 
At 5/04/2007 7:25 AM, Blogger jmc39 said...

In part and indirectly we can thank Gottlieb Simon for "advising" LT on his successful coup to be appointed executive assistant/parlimentarian.

 
At 5/04/2007 8:35 AM, Anonymous seagurll said...

Thanks, Gottlieb!

Why is Fenty giving MrT a hook up by attending his ECCA meeting in June? There's sump'n very corrupt going on when the gov't officials aren't serving the people but obsessed with preserving their own hides.

I hope Mayor Fenty is going to have nice protest when he arrives and someone asks him why he supports and is not critical of an organization that is not accountable with money it receives from the ANC's/tax payers dollars.

Maybe Lilian Gordon will put on a computer demonstration for him.

Maybe the young Mayor is too easily corrupted.

 
At 5/04/2007 10:06 AM, Anonymous OffSeventh said...

Dead on...and good points Martin

 
At 5/04/2007 12:13 PM, Anonymous Ruth said...

I would have left this comment over at Off Seventh, but comments are closed there due to a moronic tangent.

I thought it was interesting that LT expressed disapproval of Jack Evans' cursing at or in the presence of elderly women, when he is notorious for intimidating people, including elderly women, by cursing them and calling them offensive names. But I guess it is all in the same line as his and Commissioner Brooks' other behavior--truth, consistency, civility, the good of the neighborhood, ...nothing matters except their holding onto control of their "turf". It's pathetic how important it is to them to obstruct the business of the ANC, now that they no longer can run it as they wish.

Ruth

 
At 5/04/2007 1:47 PM, Blogger si said...

As a chick i can definitely tell you from personal experience, Leroy Thorpe has no problems cussing at females.

 
At 5/04/2007 1:58 PM, Anonymous rr 446 said...

i would have appreciated an update on Radio One, an official word on O Street market and other development in and around the ANC. I would have liked chairman brooks to call in the RLA and the NCPC and all the other partners who control the 7th and P parcels.
instead chairman brooks allows her friends all the time in the world to go on and on about the same situation month after month. why does SMS even need ANC approval to post signs? Shiloh church does it and they're a huge slumlord.

 
At 5/07/2007 4:54 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I still want to know if he has biological children that he talks to like this. (I have yet to receive an answer)

 

Post a Comment

<< Home